There has been a major dispute in the news recently involving India and the United States. It is ostensibly about the treatment of diplomatic staff in both countries, but the truth is far more interesting. The true motive behind Indian outrage and the subsequent endangerment of the American diplomatic outpost in New Delhi is about anti-white racism, anti-Christian bigotry, and Hindu supremacism on the part of Indians, both official and by the public.
First, the back story according to the Criminal Complaint. An Indian consular officer, this is important, Devyani Khobragade, Deputy Consul General for Political, Economic, Commercial and Women's Affairs at the Consul General's Office for the Republic of India, indicted and arrested for three felony violations of Title 18 of the United States Code (USC), sections 1001, False Statements, 1546(a) Visa Fraud, and 2, Principles. This was in relation to a visa application Khobragade caused to be submitted on behalf of Sangeeta Richard, an Indian national, hired by Khobragade as a domestic servant. Such a position requires an A-3 visa. Khobragade presented the U. S. Department of State a visa application and employment contract that was fraudulent. The law requires that a personal servant of a diplomat be subject to American employment law, including wage rates. Khobragade falsified the employment contract to make it appear to comply with American law, but in reality paid Richard significantly less than the minimum wage among other labor law violations.
The second part of the back story is the issue of diplomatic immunity. As a consular officer, and not a diplomatic officer, Khobragade holds immunity only for official acts, of which visa fraud is not one of those protected acts. Espionage is, but not visa fraud.
Subsequently Khobragade was arrested based on the complaint. She was as a matter of course, brought to the U.S. Marshals Office, who process those arrested for federal criminal offenses prior to their initial appearance before a U.S. Magistrate. At the U.S. Marshals Office, Khobragade underwent the same process as any other arrestee; search, fingerprinting and DNA collection.
Here is where the case gets interesting and Americans learn another lesson on the perils of aliens.
National Post December 18, 2013 by the Associated Press
Devyani Khobragade Reveals How She ‘Broke Down’ After ‘Stripping And Cavity Searches’ As Row Between U.S. And India Deepens
The Indian official, Devyani Khobragade, 39, who was arrested on Dec. 12, wrote in an e-mail to colleagues that she was subjected to cavity search during detention.
“I broke down many times as the indignities of repeated handcuffing, stripping and cavity searches, swabbing, in a holdup with common criminals and drug addicts were all being imposed upon me despite my incessant assertions of immunity,” she wrote.
And by interesting, it is meant the lies Khobragade tells. While an arrest entails multiple handcuffing, repeated usually means twice; once at the initial point of arrest, in this case by the Diplomatic Security Service Special Agents, and then once more after the subject is processed by the U.S. Marshals. So, for aliens, repeated means twice. And this is only the first of Khobragade's lies. Let us proceed further.
"...stripping and cavity searches..." Any experienced Federal agent would laugh hysterically at that one. First, the U.S. Marshals Service does not perform strip searches on its customer base. The first part of the procedure in the holding area in a Federal courthouse, is a search of the person arrested, even if the person was searched, and the arrestee should have been, by the arresting agents. Standard procedure is a close search of the person, the placing of the searching Deputy U.S Marshal or Detention Enforcement Officer's hands on the arrestees clothed body and the crushing and twisting of the layer of clothing in a top to bottom pattern, but not a strip search. And note here, the arrestee comes in physical contact with the searching official.
Then the next lie from Khobragade, repeated cavity searches. Another laugh, as no cavity searches are performed on arrestees except in extraordinary circumstances, commonly with hardened criminals known to commit violence in custody or terrorism suspects.
Of course, high caste Hindus are outraged apparently most of all by the search itself, as Khobragade was not the first Indian consular officer to be arrested for visa fraud relating to domestic servants.
Foreign Ministry spokesman Syed Akbaruddin said India was “shocked and appalled by the public embarrassment of the diplomat” and called for an immediate apology. India’s National Security Adviser Shivshankar Menon said it was “despicable and barbaric,” the Associated Press reported. A judge in the U.S. Southern District of New York will now decide if her arrest is justified as “a grave crime” considering her diplomatic immunity, Akbaruddin said.
And there is the rub. The mere touching of a high caste Hindu by an untouchable. For the uninitiated, Hinduism is a very primitive religion, untouched shall we say, of the consideration of ethics or reason. It is a religion based on ritual purity and the avoidance of pollution. At the center of ritual purity and pollution is caste. Ritual purity is maintained primarily by avoiding physical proximity or touching of lower castes who are polluting to a higher caste, and in the case of the Untouchables, avoiding even their shadow. In the caste system, all persons not Hindus are Untouchables, especially foreigners.
And for our controversy, the U.S. Marshals official who had the temerity to touch a high-caste Hindu, committed a grave offense in Hinduism and was insulting to all high caste Hindus, especially the Brahmins who dominate India's politics and government, note by the way, in violation of the caste system, as political power is supposed to be exercised by the Kshatriya caste.
To those with a religious or philosophical system, such an incident would be viewed rationally, as Christians do. A rational person would clearly understand the close association of arrest and search. It is no controversy at all. For Christians, truth and love are the primary philosophical aspects of their belief systems. The other is personal responsibility for ones actions in life. No Christian can be affected by the mere presence or touch another person. There is no ritual purity or pollution in Christ, there is only eventual judgement by God for one's behavior. A shadow has no effect on one's moral being, unlike the Brahim who becomes polluted by the proximity of an Untouchable.
And the Hindus know the truth about the failure of their belief system, which is why Hindus reacted so strongly to the mere touch of an Untouchable on a high caste Hindu. Hindus became enraged to hide what they knew to be true, the farcical nature of Hinduism; its ritual obsessions and its moral vacuum devoid of any introspection, intellectual reflection, and obviously ridiculous pantheon. No one considers the gods of the Greeks, Romans, or barbarians of Europe to be anything other than an inadequate attempt to deal with the vicissitudes of life and explain the natural world around them. One does not accept that Zeus, Hera and Athena existed. They were creations of unenlightened minds. However, Hindu India is the only major society that retains such a primitive religion of hundreds of gods that need appeasing.
And in their irrationality, Hindu India, has gravely threatened U.S. diplomatic personnel by withdrawing security around the American Embassy in New Delhi.
India scaled back security outside the U.S. embassy in New Delhi and revoked transit privileges for American diplomats as a row deepened over the arrest and strip-search of a consular official in New York...
India retaliated by removing concrete barricades outside the consular section of the U.S. embassy in the nation’s capital, cancelling [sic] airport passes for U.S. diplomats and freezing import requests, Foreign Minister Salman Khurshid said in parliament on Wednesday.
Clearly such an over-reaction is based on an inferiority complex, and rightly so, as India is close to a failed state, where slavery is widely practiced and plagued by caste violence. But such actions by the Indian government was, of course, an actual violation of diplomatic protocol and legal obligations India has under the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, which requires the host government to protect diplomats from attack. Such is their religious hatred of Untouchables, India will violate solemn agreements it has signed. This is hardly a nation the United States should allow immigrants to this country from. Is there no reason in India? Apparently not. They do not even understand the notion of and limitations of consular immunity.
An interesting note in this case is that Richards and her family have been rewarded for their victimization. He husband and children have been brought to the United States.
WaPo December 19, 2013
Fifth, as has been reported, the victim’s family has been brought to the United States. As also has been reported, legal process was started in India against the victim, attempting to silence her, and attempts were made to compel her to return to India. Further, the Victim’s family reportedly was confronted in numerous ways regarding this case. Speculation about why the family was brought here has been rampant and incorrect. Some focus should perhaps be put on why it was necessary to evacuate the family and what actions were taken in India vis-à-vis them. This Office and the Justice Department are compelled to make sure that victims, witnesses and their families are safe and secure while cases are pending.
It looks like another case of being a crime victim pays well in gaining U.S. residency. Of note, it appears that Richards is a Christian given her last name, or at least descendant of mixed race stock, which in India makes one an Untouchable as well. So, I don't see why Indians are so upset, but the important issue one thinks is that a cheap domestic servant is more important that ritual pollution. But ritual pollution is more important that truth and justice, as well as not as fun as burning American untouchables in effigy. Not to mention that high caste Hindus are outraged that a lower caste got to America before them.
The real question though remains, do we as Americans want people like this, obsessed with ritual purity and pollution, bringing such behavior to the United States? Is such misogyny, violence, and anti-Americanism something the United States needs?